Stop cramming it all into December.
A nonprofit fundraising plan that lives only in the last three months of the year is the most common, and most costly, habit in ministry fundraising. We had Emily Fitchpatrick on The Ministry Growth Show to talk about the fix. Emily started her career at the Billy Graham Association, founded On Eagles Wings (the first home for sex-trafficked girls in the United States), grew it from an idea to a staff of 14 and a $1.5 million budget, and now coaches ministries through her consultancy, Flagship Equip. This builds on our companion piece on the fundraising mindset shift that comes first.
Table of Contents
Why Your Fundraising Can’t Wait for December
Both Emily and I hear the same thing from ministries of every size: they save most of their fundraising for one stretch near the end of the year. Year-end campaigns are good, but the healthiest organizations map consistent fundraising and donor care across all twelve months. Emily has a great analogy for it. Your communication should look like drip coffee: a steady feed of stories, education, and updates, delivered in small, manageable pieces.
Consistency is not just kinder to your team, it is better stewardship. “The plans of the diligent lead surely to abundance, but everyone who is hasty comes only to poverty” (Proverbs 21:5, ESV). No one reads a six-page newsletter, even if it is the only thing you send all year. Bite-sized, consistent communication keeps your ministry top of mind, and it keeps donors from drifting. Leave a supporter in the dark for months and they are far more likely to forget you and move their giving to a ministry that stayed in touch. Whether you like the language or not, your ministry is a brand, and consistent communication is how brand loyalty is built.
Start With a CRM and a Year-Long Map
Emily’s first practical recommendation is infrastructure: get a donor platform, a CRM, that can track your donor base and automate some of your communication. There are hundreds of options; I will not wade into reviews here, except to say that if you are growing and can no longer give the donor care you should, it is time. For a ministry, there is no good reason, financial or otherwise, to stop consistently caring for the people who make the work possible.
Her second recommendation is the heart of a nonprofit fundraising plan: map your entire year of fundraising and donor care in advance. I spent much of my career resisting plans and schedules, convinced spontaneity was freedom. It nearly cost me my business and my peace. Done well, a plan does the opposite of what my younger self feared. As Emily put it, “When you get a clear plan, and really work the plan, it can become very freeing.” Sitting down to build an annual fundraising plan may be the single most valuable thing you do for your ministry’s growth this year.
The Three Kinds of Content Your Plan Needs: Education, Information, Inspiration
To fill that calendar without running dry, break your communication into three categories.
Education. Teaching your donors about the issue your ministry exists to address is one of the most powerful ways to build loyalty, because educated donors become advocates who share what they have learned. There is nearly endless education you can offer on your area of focus. Break it into small pieces, and wherever possible tie it to a story; data and statistics educate, but they land far harder in service of a narrative.
Information. This is where your updates live. Tell donors what is happening: what has changed in recent weeks, what new strategies you are testing. Transparency builds trust, and here too, tie it back to a life when you can. “Here is a change we made to our approach, because we believe it will help us reach people like [beneficiary] more effectively.”
Inspiration. This is your most powerful category: the stories themselves, told in words, images, and video. Whatever the medium, share how God is working through your ministry as often as you can.
Simple Ways to Stay in Touch All Year
You do not need a big production budget to communicate consistently. A few reliable, low-cost touchpoints:
- Thank-you notes. Handwritten cards, emails, texts, or quick calls. Fundraising is about relationships, and a genuine thank-you keeps you top of mind while asking nothing in return.
- Face-to-face time. Coffee (or, Emily jokes, a beer) is a great setting to share vision or update an existing donor. Schedule these across the year so you are never cramming relationships into a single fall fundraising sprint.
- Value-first content. Create something that gives a prospective donor real value, then give it away free. That is content marketing, and because the tactic is common, the value has to be genuine. A worthwhile resource also earns you a legitimate reason to ask for an email address.
Emily shared an example: a ministry she coached was sending a single piece of direct mail per year. After building a clear annual plan, they moved to four mailings, added postcards, phone calls, handwritten notes, and good-news reports, and giving rose, simply because communication did.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a nonprofit fundraising plan?
A nonprofit fundraising plan is a year-long map of your fundraising and donor-care communication, scheduled in advance so giving and relationship-building happen consistently across all twelve months rather than in a single year-end push.
Why shouldn’t we do most of our fundraising at year-end?
Year-end campaigns work, but relying on them alone leaves donors in the dark for months, and a donor who does not hear from you is more likely to forget your ministry and give elsewhere. Consistent, year-round communication builds the loyalty that sustains giving.
What should a fundraising plan actually include?
A donor CRM to track and automate communication, a calendar mapped across the year, and a mix of content in three categories, education, information, and inspiration, supported by simple touchpoints like thank-you notes, face-to-face meetings, and value-first content.
Do we need a CRM to build a fundraising plan?
Not to start, but as you grow it becomes essential. When your donor base outpaces your ability to give personal care, a CRM helps you track relationships and automate communication so no one falls through the cracks.
What are the three types of donor content?
Education (teaching donors about your cause), information (transparent updates on your work), and inspiration (the stories of transformation). Tie education and information back to a real story whenever you can, because narrative makes both far more memorable.
Do What You Can
One last word, in Emily’s own: “This can be overwhelming. Do what you can.” You do not have to build the whole calendar at once. Start with what you can sustain, pray, and add from there. A nonprofit fundraising plan is not about doing more for its own sake; it is about caring for your partners consistently, staying top of mind, and getting to share more often how the Lord is at work through you.
Building a nonprofit fundraising plan you can actually sustain is easier with a partner. Reliant Creative helps ministries design a year-round fundraising strategy and the content to fill it, so caring for your donors stops being a year-end scramble. If you want help mapping your year, we would love to talk.
